Monitor archives:
Copyrighted material

Forced Sterilization Of Europe's Roma Charges Raised

by Pavol Stracansky

European Roma Living Conditions Akin To Africa's Worst

(IPS) PRAGUE -- Czech officials are investigating claims that Roma women are still being forced to undergo sterilization.

The Czech ombudsman's office has said it is examining files handed over by the European Roma Rights Center (ERRC), a public interest law organization monitoring the situation of Roma in Europe, claiming that the practice continues even though a state-backed campaign to encourage sterilization of Roma women ended with the fall of communism.

The Roma, also known as gypsies, are a minority of Asian origin believed to have migrated to Europe since the 14th century. There are an estimated 12 million Roma in Europe, mostly in countries of the former Eastern bloc. Forced sterilization among them has been a recurring issue.

'New cases have been discovered, mainly in the north Bohemian region, for example in the town of Most,' Claude Cahn from the ERRC told the Czech daily Mlada fronta Dnes.

'Although the sterilization program ended after 1989, there are new cases where Roma women are not informed sufficiently, or the information that they would be stripped of fertility is given to them when they are giving birth or when they ask for painkillers during labor,' Cahn said.

The Czech ombudsman's office says investigations relate to cases where women are said to have undergone sterilization without being fully informed.

'These are cases from the 1990s,' deputy ombudsman Anna Sabatova told Czech media. 'The complaints say that the women allegedly were not sterilized according to the law as they did not give their informed consent.'

The ERRC says the cases it has turned over to the ombudsman are 'not the only cases of coercive sterilization of Roma women in the Czech Republic of which we are aware.'

It says these are cases where several factors 'including but not limited to the willingness of the victim to pursue legal measures under present conditions, our independent assessment of the victim's ability to endure difficult legal proceedings, as well as a number of other factors, have converged to make formal complaints possible.'

Under Czech law sterilization can be carried out only if a woman has four children, or if she has three children but is over 35, or if a new pregnancy poses a threat to life. But in all cases a woman must request the operation.

The ERRC claim over forced sterilization comes after Human Rights Watch and other groups reported in the 1990s that the practice had ended with the fall of communism in 1989.

It is widely believed that Roma women were coerced to undergo sterilization under communist state birth control programs. Many Roma women were reportedly offered financial incentives.

Rights groups say the program was a way of capping the population of the minority group. Birth rates among the Roma remain higher than in the rest of the Czech population.

The Roma minority in both the Czech Republic and Slovakia, estimated at 300,000 and 500,000 respectively, say they are victims of systematic racial persecution and prejudice. They claim they are denied equal education opportunities and that they suffer from employment discrimination.

Reports of forced sterilization in the Czech Republic come a year after the government in neighboring Slovakia was forced to investigate claims by NGO groups of similar practices there.

A government investigation found no evidence to support the claims but NGOs said the investigation was not thorough enough.

The Czech government has already accused the ERRC of giving a wrong picture. 'The European Roma Rights Center has been making this claim for two years,' government commissioner for human rights Jan Jarab told Czech Radio. 'That is not true.'

Jarab added: 'I cannot say if there has or has not been an individual case of an involuntary sterilization in a Roma or non-Roma woman, because first there would have to be an individual plaintiff and it would have to be investigated. Then if the authorities tried not to investigate this or cover it up, it could be said that the Czech Republic tolerates such a phenomenon.'

Some doctors have also cast doubt on the ERRC claims. Vit Unzeitig from the Czech Gynaecological and Obstetrics Society told Mlada fronta Dnes that he has never come across a case of forced sterilization though 'it is true that at present doctors recommend sterilization to women with many children but Roma women mostly refuse this.'

Comments? Send a letter to the editor.

Albion Monitor September 23, 2004 (

All Rights Reserved.

Contact for permission to use in any format.